critical reading

Submitted by Olga Koz on October 14th, 2024
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

The literature review design (LRD) tool helps design a traditional review nested in the dissertation or thesis. It was created based on the interactive Hopscotch research design framework (Jorrin-Abellan, 2020). 

  • Students are asked to answer questions in the LRD form and engage with resources in the Guide to LRD. 
  • Students may stop working on the form (after steps 3, 5, and 6) and submit preliminary results (Save & Submit).
  •  Ultimately, they will receive the graphical representation of the literature review (table) and literature review protocol. 
Attachments: 
AttachmentSize
LRD Form_Graphic_24.docxdisplayed 460 times366 KB
AttachmentSize
TLED9900LR-Syllabus-Summer 2024.docxdisplayed 877 times91.78 KB
Learning Outcomes: 
  • Evaluate the role that literature review has in planning research.
  • Differentiate between the types/genres of literature reviews, their methodology, strengths, limitations, and sources of bias, and select the appropriate type of review.
  • Distinguish between the types and levels of evidence/literature/publications and select the appropriate ones for review.
  • Develop and apply the systematic literature-searching strategy and the protocol for evidence collection.
  • Frame the proposed research theoretically and conceptually
  • Reveal research, conceptual, and methodological gaps.
  • Sharpen critical thinking skills while analyzing and appraising evidence.
  • Synthesize the literature analysis results to inform your study's research questions, design, and framework.
  • Submit the draft of the literature review for a dissertation proposal or Chapter 2 of the dissertation.
Discipline: 
Education

Individual or Group:

Course Context (e.g. how it was implemented or integrated): 

The LRD tool was a formative and summative assignment for the course "Literature review for Ed.D. students." Each step in designing the literature review protocol included various activities ( watching a video tutorial, answering questions, or attending search and analysis sessions.

Additional Instructor Resources (e.g. in-class activities, worksheets, scaffolding applications, supplemental modules, further readings, etc.): 

The course syllabus includes activities (video and other self-paced tutorials, working on the interactive form, AI applications).

Assessment or Criteria for Success
(e.g. rubric, guidelines, exemplary sample paper, etc.): 
AttachmentSize
LR_Rubric.docxdisplayed 410 times21.3 KB
Assessment Short Description: 
Literature Review rubrics
Potential Pitfalls and Teaching Tips: 
Suggested Citation: 
Koz, Olga. "Dissertation's Literature Review." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2024. https://projectcora.org/assignment/dissertations-literature-review.
Submitted by Stephanie Geller on October 1st, 2021
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

A lesson plan for a 45-minute lower-division Sociology class. The texts used in the plan are Elijah Anderson (1999) Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City and Thomas L. McNulty and Paul E. Bellair (2003), “Explaining Racial and Ethnic Differences in Serious Adolescent Violent Behavior,” which the students were to have read in advance.

Attachments: 
AttachmentSize
Critical Reading-Lesson Plan for a 45-minute Sociology classdisplayed 785 times22.36 KB
Learning Outcomes: 

Introduce students to critical reading skills to support their ability to complete the readings and extract important topics and ideas. Have students practice critical reading skills: 1) identify key elements of a text, 2) reflect on how methods, structure, and presentation impact their reception of a text’s arguments, and 3) become more comfortable sharing their experiences with each other and considering how and why different people have different reactions to the same text. 

Discipline: 
Sociology

Individual or Group:

Suggested Citation: 
Geller, Stephanie. "Critical Reading Lesson Plan - Lower Division Sociology." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2021. https://projectcora.org/assignment/critical-reading-lesson-plan-lower-division-sociology.
Submitted by Sala Shierling on September 28th, 2021
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

This sample activity corresponds to a chapter in the upcoming (2022) ACRL title: Teaching Critical Reading Skills: Strategies for Academic Librarians.

Learning Outcomes: 

The student will apply practical critical reading skills to a variety of pre-sources in order to select, search, identify, and retrieve pertinent information sources.

Discipline: 
Psychology

Individual or Group:

Suggested Citation: 
Shierling, Sala. "Critically Reading the Pre-Source (Putting It All Together - A Popular Source Connection)." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2021. https://projectcora.org/assignment/critically-reading-pre-source-putting-it-all-together-popular-source-connection.
Submitted by Sala Shierling on September 28th, 2021
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

This sample activity corresponds to a chapter in the upcoming (2022) ACRL title: Teaching Critical Reading Skills: Strategies for Academic Librarians.

Learning Outcomes: 

The student will apply practical critical reading skills to Help Sheets in order to identify methods for searching, identifying, evaluating, and assessing pertinent information sources.

Discipline: 
Psychology

Information Literacy concepts:

Suggested Citation: 
Shierling, Sala. "Critically Reading the Pre-Source (Help Sheets - Fields, Document types, and Methodologies)." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2021. https://projectcora.org/assignment/critically-reading-pre-source-help-sheets-fields-document-types-and-methodologies.
Submitted by Sala Shierling on September 28th, 2021
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

This sample activity corresponds to a chapter in the upcoming (2022) ACRL title: Teaching Critical Reading Skills: Strategies for Academic Librarians.

Attachments: 
AttachmentSize
Critical Reading Activity Example - Activity 6 - Critically Reading the Thesaurusdisplayed 750 times361.67 KB
Learning Outcomes: 

The student will apply practical critical reading skills to identify discipline specific terminology in order to find pertinent information sources.

Discipline: 
Psychology

Information Literacy concepts:

Individual or Group:

Suggested Citation: 
Shierling, Sala. "Critically Reading the Pre-Source (Database Thesaurus)." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2021. https://projectcora.org/assignment/critically-reading-pre-source-database-thesaurus.
Submitted by Sala Shierling on September 28th, 2021
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

This sample activity corresponds to a chapter in the upcoming (2022) ACRL title: Teaching Critical Reading Skills: Strategies for Academic Librarians.

Attachments: 
AttachmentSize
Critical Reading Activity Example - Activity 5 - Critically Reading the Author Indexdisplayed 804 times167.21 KB
Learning Outcomes: 

The student will apply practical critical reading skills in order identify key contributors and writings in the psychology discipline

Discipline: 
Psychology

Individual or Group:

Suggested Citation: 
Shierling, Sala. "Critically Reading the Pre-Source (Author Index)." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2021. https://projectcora.org/assignment/critically-reading-pre-source-author-index.
Submitted by Sala Shierling on September 28th, 2021
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

This sample activity corresponds to a chapter in the upcoming (2022) ACRL title: Teaching Critical Reading Skills: Strategies for Academic Librarians.

Learning Outcomes: 

The student will apply practical critical reading skills in order to distinguish primary and secondary empirical research studies. 

Discipline: 
Psychology

Individual or Group:

Suggested Citation: 
Shierling, Sala. "Critically Reading the Pre-Source (Abstract to determine secondary or primary research)." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2021. https://projectcora.org/assignment/critically-reading-pre-source-abstract-determine-secondary-or-primary-research.
Submitted by Sala Shierling on September 28th, 2021
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

This sample activity corresponds to a chapter in the upcoming (2022) ACRL title: Teaching Critical Reading Skills: Strategies for Academic Librarians.

Attachments: 
AttachmentSize
Critical Reading Activity Example - Activity 3 - Critically Reading the Pre-Sourcedisplayed 732 times761.29 KB
Learning Outcomes: 

The student will apply practical critical reading skills in order to determine source pertinence for an information need.

Discipline: 
Psychology

Individual or Group:

Course Context (e.g. how it was implemented or integrated): 
Additional Instructor Resources (e.g. in-class activities, worksheets, scaffolding applications, supplemental modules, further readings, etc.): 
Potential Pitfalls and Teaching Tips: 
Suggested Citation: 
Shierling, Sala. "Critically Reading the Pre-Source (Full Citations)." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2021. https://projectcora.org/assignment/critically-reading-pre-source-full-citations.
Submitted by Sala Shierling on September 28th, 2021
Share this on: 
Short Description: 

This sample activity corresponds to a chapter in the upcoming (2022) ACRL title: Teaching Critical Reading Skills: Strategies for Academic Librarians.

Attachments: 
AttachmentSize
Critical Reading Activity Example - Activity 1 - Critically Reading the Pre-Sourcedisplayed 954 times310.47 KB
Learning Outcomes: 

The student will apply practical critical reading skills in order to determine database (information resource) relevancy to an information need.

Discipline: 
Psychology

Individual or Group:

Course Context (e.g. how it was implemented or integrated): 
Additional Instructor Resources (e.g. in-class activities, worksheets, scaffolding applications, supplemental modules, further readings, etc.): 
Potential Pitfalls and Teaching Tips: 
Suggested Citation: 
Shierling, Sala. "Critically Reading the Pre-Source (Scope Notes/Database Descriptions)." CORA (Community of Online Research Assignments), 2021. https://projectcora.org/assignment/critically-reading-pre-source-scope-notesdatabase-descriptions.